‘Miracle and Wonder: Conversations with Paul Simon’ by Malcolm Gladwell

This is the best use of the audiobook format. You listen to conversations held by Malcolm Gladwell and his colleague, journalist Bruce Headlam, with the legendary singer songwriter Paul Simon; you hear him talk about his creative process and share interesting tidbits along the way; you hear myths debunked from Gladwell’s trademark inquiries; you discover new personal insights. Above all, you can hear the music icon who had created many world famous tunes over his 65 year career, now at 80, pick up his guitar and sing his own songs or listen to the recordings that had made him and his singing duo Art Garfunkel a household name. And more, you can hear reflections from other influential musicians like Renee Fleming, Sting, Herbie Hancock… For me, this listening experience has opened the floodgate of reminiscence and memories.

A myth debunked. No, Simon didn’t write his breakout hit “The Sound of Silence” in the subway under hauntingly existential circumstances, but in the bathroom of his parents’ house. The walls were tiled and the water running, he played his guitar in the dark and could hear echoes. He was 22. That was all he remembers now. No matter, that tune and the lyrics had sent echoes to the heart and soul of millions around the world.

The inspiration of “Bridge Over Troubled Waters” came from a line in the Black Gospel singer Rev. Claude Jeter’s (1914-2009) song “Mary Don’t You Weep”–– it says “I’ll be a bridge over deep water if you trust in my name,” a Biblical metaphor. While the title and lyrics were sparked by Jeter’s Gospel song, the melody was inspired by J. S. Bach. Another interesting tidbit is that sound engineer Roy Halee reminisces that it took him more than 100 hours to make the recording of “Bridge Over Troubled Water” as they explored different mixes of sound effects. Simon notes that the song had rippled to many different stylings and sung by so many others that he doesn’t feel it’s his own anymore. And he’s fine with that. In particular, he pays tribute to Aretha Franklin’s soulful rendition.

A poignant moment. When the first “Saturday Night Live” came back on after the tragedy of 9-11, the producer called Simon and asked him to perform in his show. I think you have to do “The Boxer”, he said. An iconic New Yorker song, a fighter that carries the reminders of being struck down yet still remains with resilience and tenacity. In the audiobook, Simon recollects that he had tried to put words in the bridging stanza but none came and so he decided to just use “lie la lie…lie lie lie lie lie lie lie lie la lie…” not knowing such wordless echoes would cross linguistic borders when live audience around the would join in spontaneously when he performed.

Where to locate Paul Simon? He refuses to be called a folk singer. His songs inspired by very different sources. His creative process often sparked by distant memories of tunes and rhythms. After the breakup with Garfunkel, he ventured into a musical fusion of cultures and stylings. Gladwell spends some time talking with Simon about how the song “Take Me to the Mardi Gras” came to be. There are at least five sources of creative contributions: the Black Gospel singer Claude Jeter, R & B musicians from Alabama, a New Orlean jazz brass band, Jamaica reggae, and plausibly, according to Gladwell’s instinct, a Yiddish riff. Such freedom to adapt different cultural roots in his compositions leads him later to his album “Graceland.”

Herein lies Gladwell’s sensibility, one I totally embrace and thanks to him, lays out in words the notion that has long lodged in my mind. Using Simon as an exemplar, a Jewish singer songwriter from Queens, NY, Gladwell says:

As a New Yorker, your cultural identity is something you get to hold loosely. It influences you, but it doesn’t define you. You’re free to roam and window shop and come up with your own combination.

The melting pot theory debunked––as attuned to Nathan Glazer’s social theory in Beyond the Melting Pot––well, at least in NYC during Simon’s early creative decades, this kind of freedom existed. But isn’t that a true requirement for one to be a global citizen, a member of our shared humanity, transcending ethnic borders and arbitrary barriers? Unfortunately, such a fluid cultural perspective has shifted in recent years to a narrow view demanding artists, writers, filmmakers… to stay in their cultural lane, to use Gladwell’s metaphor.

Another fascinating tidbit…wait till you get to where Gladwell links taste with memory when he talks about how Stephen Sondheim regrets that his lyrics in the “West Side Story” song “Maria” aren’t quite right, and then goes on to discuss with Simon about finding faults in his own compositions. BTW, “Homeward Bound” is Simon’s “Maria.”

Another issue Gladwell investigates is the mystery of longevity in the creative process, using David Galenson’s book Old Masters and Young Geniuses to compare and analyze why some artists hit their peaks as young prodigies while others are late bloomers, sustaining a long creative journey. Where to locate Paul Simon in this spectrum? I’ll leave that interesting topic for you to experience when you listen to this exceptional audiobook.

~ ~ ~ ~ Ripples

Miracle and Wonder: Conversations with Paul Simon by Malcolm Gladwell and Bruce Headlam with Paul Simon, audiobook ©2021 Pushkin Industries and Paul Simon (P)2021 Pushkin Industries and Paul Simon


Published by


If she’s not birding by the Pond, Arti’s likely watching a movie, reading, or writing a review. Creator of Ripple Effects, bylines in Asian American Press, Vague Visages, Curator Magazine.

12 thoughts on “‘Miracle and Wonder: Conversations with Paul Simon’ by Malcolm Gladwell”

  1. I took a “Master Class” with Malcom Gladwell on writing and loved it. He does do his research.
    Thank you for the suggestion!


    1. What a privilege to learn from MG on writing. You must listen to him chatting with Paul Simon here. I’m sure you’ll enjoy his insights and analyses. And of course, the music in this audiobook.


  2. Arti,

    An exceptional review of an exceptional audiobook!

    I bought my first S & G album The Sounds of Silence in 1966/67. I was 14/15.
    Listening to Miracle & Wonder was also very nostalgic for me. But there’s so, so, much more to absorp and digest. I’m listening it for the the 3rd time but I’m afraid it may take me ten more times to take in everything. I wasn’t familiar with Simon’s songs after he parted ways with Garfunkel, didn’t know he continued to be so productive/prolific, even including a Broadway musical. I vaguely remember the album Graceland, just knew it was his first album going solo, but knew nothing about his motivation behind it, the songs, and the controversy surrounding it.

    As always a great post! It inspires me to head out to look for Simon’s works after his split with Garfunkel .


    1. Thanks for your thoughts and sharing. Yes, those of us from that ‘era’ would have fond memories and can’t help but being nostalgic. 😉


  3. This sounds like a book MADE to be an audio book — a brilliant musician so you can hear some of the music as well as the voice. I’m not one for audio books but I think this would be the way to do this one.


      1. I finished it last week — loved it so much!! Your review is great, and I echo your statement, “For me, this listening experience has opened the floodgate of reminiscence and memories.”

        In the last third of the story — which isn’t exactly a book, is it? — I was not so engaged as at the beginning, because I hadn’t kept up with Simon after “Graceland,” and also I began to tire of Malcolm Gladwell’s analysis and interpretation of everything. But I commend him for his own creative effort in putting the whole thing together. It’s one to keep in my library and listen to again.


        1. I agree with you about MG may be interpreting too much. Maybe he’s correct in some observations, but sometimes I feel he makes too wide a definite conclusion. However, he does have some unique insights. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed it. BTW, the floodgate of memories just places us into the era we were in. 🙂

          Liked by 1 person

  4. Amazing that he was so young when he wrote Sound of Silence. I taught that on the piano a girl who didn’t play at all but needed to learn some for her music GCSE and was impressed by the depth of the lyrics and the haunting chords.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There are lots of background stories too, and the ‘making-of’ tidbits in the composition and recording of his most memorable songs. You must listen to this audiobook. You’ll love it, Denise. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s