‘The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” by F. Scott Fitzgerald

Thanks to the 1920 Club, I’ve the chance to explore the short stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald. After reading his debut short story collection Flappers and Philosophers which was published in 1920, and now that the week of the Club read has passed, I continue with seeking out more of FSF’s works published in subsequent years.

BB Book CoverAs I can’t go to bookstores now, I turn to my shelves to see what I have in my stockpile, and unearthed this one which I’ve never read: A designer’s copy of FSF’s short story first published in 1922, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, in hard cover and fully illustrated, a thin little gem hidden between thicker books. Illustrated by Calef Brown, published by Collins Design, NY, in 2008 when the movie adaptation came out.

What could have motivated Fitzgerald to write a story about a baby born as an old man then gradually grows younger and younger, creating an imaginary scenario that’s opposite of the human trajectory? FSF’s reply had been cited as thus:

‘This story was inspired by a remark of Mark Twain’s to the effect that it was a pity that the best part of life came at the beginning and the worst part at the end.” FSF seems to be offering a hypothetical answer with a question: Is growing younger necessarily more cheerful than growing older?

All along I’m aware of the premise of the story. So with much curiosity I open and read it through.

BB1

First off, no need to use logic or your rational mind to wrap around this scientifically impossible happening. Just take it as a fantasy and let curiosity be the guide. The setting is 1860 and forward in Baltimore. Benjamin is born to Mr. Roger Button, president of Roger Button & Co., Wholesale Hardware, a well-off businessman and a respected figure in the community.

The baby is born with a long beard, “a man of threescore and ten”, in other words, 70 years old, with a ready-formed personality and full mastery of speech to communicate with his dumbfounded father, whose immediate reaction is this:

Mr. Button, sank down upon a chair near his son and concealed his face in his hands. “My heavens!” he murmured, in an ecstasy of horror. “What will people say? What must I do?”

Have you caught it? Indeed, what he’s worried is what people will say about this horrifically different offspring of his.

What follows is a story, while whimsical, is quite sad. Mr. Roger has trouble accepting this undefined being in his home. Fitzgerald’s storytelling is light humour with an acerbic tone. His father calls him Benjamin, albeit a more appropriate name in his mind at first was Methuselah. Benjamin ‘grows up’ being ostracized due to age disparity among his peers, barred from Yale University for his advanced age (I’m sure by now the system has changed). One good thing is, later he does find a young woman to marry, Hildegarde Moncrief, daughter of a general, for by that time the age gap though still large is overcome by love.

BB2

But as years go by, as Benjamin becomes more youthful and Hildegarde much older, he begins to grow tired of her, and their relationship deteriorates. Some years later, he has  turned so youthful that his son feels uncomfortable to be seen with him and his grandson surpasses him in intellect. Eventually, Benjamin degenerates into a state without memory, a baby that responds to mere instinctive urges. Despite the lively book illustrations, this is actually a very sad story.

This curious case reads like a cautionary tale of Ageism that applies both ways: one can be discriminated for being too old, or too young. Fitzgerald could well be using a fanciful tale to depict the norms of social acceptance which seem to be strictly dependent on appearances. Further, in response to Mark Twain’s comment that first prompted the story, Fitzgerald seems to conclude that what an old man has but a baby doesn’t is the wealth of memory he has stored throughout the years. Without an iota of memory, does that make it ‘the best part of life’?

A cautionary tale? Maybe. A whimsical literary farce? That too. Definitely something that’s very different from FSF’s other realistic stories of the Jazz Age.

 

***

 

 

 

Published by

Arti

If she’s not birding by the Pond, Arti’s likely watching a movie, reading, or writing a review. Bylines in Asian American Press, Vague Visages, Curator Magazine.

13 thoughts on “‘The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” by F. Scott Fitzgerald”

  1. Arti,

    I remember watching the film starring Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett, but wasn’t aware that it was based on a short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald. I remember thinking that the film was rather strange and forgettable.
    Thanks to your post I am enlightened, and would like to watch it again and maybe read the Fitzgerald’s short story, to find out if “growing younger is more cheerful than growing older.”

    Yinling

    Like

      1. I preferred the story! I liked the story’s concise way of bringing together many things. It was good to see something different made out of it, though, it’s very rare I read and watch both versions as it seems a waste of time if too samey. Visual effects very good I agree but it was a bit sentimental. I think Cate Blanchett’s excellent performance made it a better film than its script.

        Like

        1. Interesting, Denise. I personally prefer the more fledged out movie. I know it’s a bit longer than usual. I don’t like the tone of the short story, surely FSF could have meant it to be a light-hearted satire, but he’d left out a lot of human sentiments, e.g. the mother’s POV. In the movie, it makes amends in a way for the lack of motherly influence, and the love that’s totally absent in BB’s home life (other than the short-lived love affair with his wife) in the short story is now taken to a more gratifying scenario. I quite like the “sentimental”, melodramatic elements of the movie. 🙂

          Like

  2. Is Benjamin’s mother mentioned at all in the story? I like how things are. We are born so very young, and hopefully grow in wisdom, age, and grace!
    God bless, C-Marie

    Like

    1. Good question. I had that query too when I was reading. No, the mother isn’t mentioned except in a few places the phrase “Mr. and Mrs. Roger Button”. That in itself is strange.

      Like

  3. I’ve read the story, but I didn’t like it much. All the characters judged each other on prejudice rather than on what they were.
    I get his point, but there are better stories which express the same idea in a more realistic way.

    Like

    1. I admit I didn’t embrace the story either. As I mentioned in my post, the tone is acerbic, and yes, prejudice seems to be the norm. So I’m giving the credit to FSF that this is a farce mocking the social norm he had observed. I’ll discuss the film next, which I appreciate much more.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. “Fitzgerald was named after his deceased sister, Louise Scott Fitzgerald, one of two sisters who died shortly before his birth. “Well, three months before I was born,” he wrote as an adult, “my mother lost her other two children … I think I started then to be a writer.”

    Such a sad, sad, life. Just read the account on Wikipedia, as I knew him not at all.

    God bless, C-Marie

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I never would have imagined that Fitzgerald would write this one. It seems so out of his zone. But what an interesting fantasy. I never saw the film, although I heard Pitt was excellent. Well, maybe someday if I ever get out of here…

    Like

    1. I never realised that FSF wrote this story either, but I really enjoyed it. I found it amazing to think what varied styles he was capable of, and the lighter tone hid some deep themes about prejudice, about society, in a very short piece of work. There were also deep themes of loneliness, of family relationships and resentments, of shame, of personal goals, and back to society, what success is, or our view of it. Onto the film now (it does look long in comparison, and I’m right at the beginning, can’t understand who these characters are!)

      Like

Leave a Reply to jo(e) Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s